Charlie Gard's disease and legal case: An explainer

An American doctor traveled to the United Kingdom to meet with specialists treating Charlie Gard, the terminally ill baby whose parents are fighting in court to keep alive.

Dr. Michio Hirano of Columbia University spoke with doctors from Great Ormond Street Hospital and will meet with Charlie’s mother, Connie Yates, on Tuesday.

Charlie’s parents have raised more than $1.6 million to take their son to the United States for an experimental treatment. Great Ormond Street Hospital, where Charlie is being treated, has intended to turn off his life support as multiple courts have ruled that prolonging the baby’s life would only cause him greater pain.

But the hospital applied for a fresh hearing on July 7 because of “new evidence relating to the potential treatment for his condition” presented by researchers at the Vatican’s children’s hospital and another medical facility outside of Britain.

Chris Gard and Connie Yates, Charlie’s parents, have been allowed to present new evidence to prove their son should receive experimental treatment. Hirano was allowed to examine Charlie to determine if he would be eligible for such treatment.

Hirano’s research focuses on mitochondrial diseases and genetic myopathies. He has treated other people with similar conditions to that of Charlie’s.

High Court Judge Nicholas Francis said that he would be “open-minded about the evidence” Hirano will submit to him.

“There is not a person alive who would not want to save Charlie,” Francis has said. “If there is new evidence I will hear it.”

Charlie’s case has drawn worldwide attention from religious leaders, celebrities and President Donald Trump. A hospital in New York City has also offered to “admit and evaluate” Charlie.

Read on to find out more about Charlie Gard and the case that’s gone international.

Who is Charlie Gard?

At 11 months old, Charlie Gard suffers from the rare genetic condition Mitochondrial DNA depletion syndrome. He has brain damage and is unable to breathe on his own.

Charlie was born on Aug. 4, 2016, according to a GoFundMe account set up by his mother. While he was healthy at birth, Charlie soon took a turn for the worse.

“We took him into [the] hospital at 8 weeks old and none of us have been anywhere near home since,” Yates wrote.


He has been receiving treatment at Great Ormond Street Hospital in London since October. There, he is on life support — although it’s not clear how much longer the hospital will allow him to remain on the machines.

Charlie’s parents have hoped to take their son to the U.S. for an experimental treatment, but doctors disagreed, arguing that prolonging his medical care would just prolong his pain and suffering.

Yates said there is a new oral medication treatment available which “could potentially repair Charlie’s [mitochondrial DNA] and help it synthase again by giving him the naturally occurring compounds that his body isn’t able to produce.”

If Charlie isn’t able to travel to receive the treatment, Yates said in a since-deleted GoFundMe post that the family would use the money to “make sure that other innocent babies and children will be saved,” the BBC reported.

GoFundMe is reportedly in talks with the family to determine what would happen to the money if they can’t use it for Charlie’s care.


What is Mitochondrial DNA depletion syndrome?

Mitochondrial DNA depletion syndrome is an inherited disease that damages the body’s organs as it blocks energy from getting to organs.

Since the brain, heart, liver, muscles and kidneys all use a lot of energy, those organs can be affected the most by a mitochondrial disease, including this one, according to the Cincinnati Children’s Hospital. The respiratory system can also be affected.


While symptoms can vary among people who have mitochondrial diseases, those affected can experience muscle weakness, heart disease, seizures, breathing problems and developmental delay, according to the hospital.

For Charlie, “his brain, muscle and ability to breathe are all severely affected,” a professor who specializes in mitochondrial diseases said about the baby. “In addition, he has congenital deafness and a severe epilepsy disorder.”

While there are no cures yet for mitochondrial diseases, there are some treatments available that can reduce symptoms. However, treatments aren’t guaranteed to work for every person, according to the Cincinnati Children’s Hospital.

Vitamins, cofactors and therapies have been helpful for some patients.

Respiratory failure is the most common death among those affected with the disease, according to the National Institute of Health’s online library. And rarely do those inflicted with the disease survive into adolescence or adulthood, according to NIH.

So why did the UK legal system intervene in this case?

Specialists at Great Ormond Street Hospital said they had exhausted all proven treatment efforts and wanted to take Charlie off life support. But Charlie’s parents pushed back and argued that they should be able to take their son out of the country for experimental treatment.

Doctors at the hospital went to the legal system and asked the courts to decide if they could remove Charlie from life support, without parental consent, if they deemed it to be in the child’s best interest.

In April 2017, a judge ruled that doctors could take Charlie off life support.


“It is with the heaviest of hearts but with complete conviction for Charlie’s best interests that I find it is in Charlie’s best interests that I accede to these applications and rule that GOSH may lawfully withdraw all treatment save for palliative care to permit Charlie to die with dignity,” Francis said.

Charlie’s parents appealed that decision — and others — until they reached the European Court of Human Rights and asked it to hear their case. The ECHR, in Strasbourg, France, rejected the plea and sided with the other courts’ decisions.

The court’s decision is “final,” according to the Telegraph.

But the hospital applied for a new hearing after it said it received “new evidence relating to potential treatment for his condition,” the BBC reported.

Seven medical experts disclosed to the hospital unpublished data relating to a potential cure for Charlie’s brain damage, according to the BBC.

“Two international hospitals and their researchers have communicated to us as late as the last 24 hours that they have fresh evidence about their proposed experimental treatment,” a hospital spokesperson said.

The hospital said that its view on Charlie’s treatment had not changed but wanted to give “the High Court the opportunity to objectively assess the claims of fresh evidence.”

“We believe, in common with Charlie’s parents, it is right to explore this evidence,” the spokesperson said, according to the BBC.

The hospital is currently bound by court rulings barring it from sending Charlie anywhere for the experimental treatment. The rulings also say the baby’s artificial ventilation should be withdrawn and he should receive only palliative care.

As the new hearing got underway on July 10, Francis refused to grant Charlie’s parent’s request for a new judge.

“I did my job. I will continue to do my job,” Francis said.

But he did give the couple a few days to gather new evidence to present.

What has been the response from world leaders?

“I am confident that Great Ormond Street Hospital have and always will consider any offers of new information that has come forward for the wellbeing of a desperately ill child,” British Prime Minister Theresa May told the House of Commons on July 5.

“It’s an unimaginable position to be in. I fully understand and appreciate that any parent in this circumstances would want to do everything possible and explore every option for their seriously ill child,” May continued. “But I know no doctor wants to be in this terrible position where they have to make such heartbreaking decisions.”

Religious and world leaders publicly oppose the court’s decision.


President Donald Trump tweeted on July 3 that the U.S. would be “delighted” to help Charlie.

“Upon learning of baby Charlie Gard’s situation, President Trump has offered to help the family in this heartbreaking situation,” Helen Ferre, director of White House media relations, said in a statement.

She added that Trump did “not want to pressure” the family as he is “just trying to be helpful if at all possible.”

Trump’s support gave Yates “hope,” she told Sky News.

A family spokesperson also confirmed to the news outlet that White House officials have spoken to Charlie’s parents, the hospital, the UK government and the American doctor who thinks he can help the baby.

Legislation has been introduced in the U.S. House of Representatives by Rep. Trent Franks, R-Ariz., and Rep. Brad Wenstrup, R-Ohio, which might give Charlie and his parents residency in the U.S. 

“Our proposed legislation grants lawful permanent status in the U.S. to Charlie Gard and his family, so they are at least enabled to pursue their best hope for Charlie,” they said in a statement

Pope Francis has called for the parents to be allowed to do everything possible to treat their son, amending the Vatican’s previous position after conservatives complained.

In a statement, the Vatican press office said Francis “is following with affection and sadness the case of little Charlie Gard and expresses his closeness to his parents. For this he prays that their wish to accompany and treat their child until the end is not neglected.”

Vatican-owned Pediatric Hospital Bambino Gesu — commonly called the “Pope’s Hospital” — has offered to take in Charlie and treat him.

New York Presbyterian Hospital and Columbia Medical Center agreed to admit the boy, if he can be sent “safely” there, with legal issues “cleared,” the hospital told CBS News in a statement. The hospital said it would also have to get the FDA’s “emergency approval” for the boy’s experimental treatment. 

“Alternatively, if approved by the FDA, we will arrange shipment of the experimental drug to Great Ormond Street Hospital and advise their medical staff on administering it if they are willing to do so,” the hospital said. 

How have celebrities reacted?

Singer Cher supports allowing Charlie Gard to come to the U.S. for treatment.

In an emoji-laden tweet on July 3, Cher said “institutions have no right [to] flip switch on beloved” baby.

“If [the U.S.] can save precious Charlie Gard … send him [to] us,” she said.

British model Tamara Ecclestone has also donated to Charlie’s parents’ online fundraising site.

An Instagram account set up to document “Charlie’s Fight” thanked actress Linda Robson for her support.

The Associated Press contributed to this report. 

Source link